ALLAH, créateur de l’univers, ne maîtrise pas des calculs niveau collège, et toi ?

Allah, créateur de l'univers, ne maîtrise pas des calculs niveau collège, et toi ?

https://www.reddit.com/r/exmuslim/comments/98rpd8/qurans_mathematical_errors_in_inheritance/

Allah's rules of inheritance are laid out in Quran 4:11-12 and 4:176.
It is difficult to overstate how poorly written and poorly thought out these verses are.
When reading them, I feel that I am actually entering Muhammad's overwhelmed mind, in which he is trying to come up with verses that can account for multiple scenarios (multiple siblings, multiple children, etc.), but that Muhammad is in way over his head and can't pull it off.
4:11 even starts out badly with Allah incorrectly using the phrase “more than two” when He must mean “two or more.”
But the greatest problem with Allah's inheritance rules is that they result in multiple situations in which the total of the inheritance pie adds up to more than 100%. It is an extraordinary mathematical error by the Creator of the Universe.
Example 1:
A deceased man leaves behind a wife, two daughters, a mother and father. The wife receives ⅛. The two daughters share ⅔. The mother and father each get ⅙. Per the Quran's math, the total combined is 1 ⅛. Oops.
(The comparative Sunni and Shia adjustments can be found at “Al-Awl,” al-islam.org)
Example 2:
A deceased woman leaves behind a husband and two sisters. The husband receives ½ and the sisters share ⅔. Per the Quran's math, the total is 1 ⅙. Oops.
(The comparative Sunni and Shia adjustments can be found in Shabaz Ahmad Cheema, Shia and Sunni Laws of Inheritance: A Comparative Analysis, 77-78)
For fun, go to www.inheritancecalculator.net, a Sunni inheritance calculator, and type those two scenarios in. You will receive the message: “Total shares have exceeded 100%. Shares need to be reduced proportionally,” and the website does so through a process called awl. The problem is that nowhere does the Quran or Muhammad say to “reduce proportionally.” It is simply a method developed by humans to fix the mathematical error.
But Shia jurisprudence rejects awl, and solves the mathematical error differently, which highlights that there is no clear prescription on how to solve the Quran's mathematical error.
In Islam, the Creator of Two Trillion Galaxies can't add fractions.

Le 22 avril 2021 à 10:30:46 :
Ah oui si non tu as les vidéos de Majid sur youtube, parce que l'odeur de ton pavé...

Les anglophobes peuvent traduire ici : https://www.deepl.com/fr/translator